Who Peaceable Calls it a ‘Glass Ceiling?’ No longer the 6 Ladies Working for President

‘Shake the desk.’ ‘Atomize issues.’ ‘Persist.’ These are the metaphors of a brand unique technology of political candidates.

Credit scoreCredit scoreDrew Angerer/Getty Pictures

Kamala Harris is able to “ruin issues.”

Elizabeth Warren said she would “persist.”

Amy Klobuchar has challenged voters to good buy ladies folks “at your like anxiety,” while Tulsi Gabbard insisted that a presidential disappear with six ladies folks just isn’t any longer an anomaly but “what an election have to restful sight treasure.”

The ladies folks running for president are promising many issues as they compose their pitches to voters. They’re being asked time and but over again how being ladies folks might well perhaps additionally impact their chances. Nonetheless up to now, none of them are emphasizing the “glass ceiling.”

In actuality, the phrase “glass ceiling” used to be trending no longer too long ago no longer thanks to anything the candidates had said, but thanks to Nike. In an advert celebrating the World Cup-winning U.S. ladies folks’s soccer team, a narrator intones, over black and white imagery of the avid gamers, the “I have confidence about” chant — finishing up it to suppose that girls folks will “overcome bigger than merely the soccer area, treasure breaking each glass ceiling.”

The logo remains intact. In politics, the phrase became connected to the aspirations of Hillary Clinton, who spoke at key moments of success and defeat about cracking the glass ceiling. Nonetheless on this barrier-breaking area of female candidates, it is noticeably absent.

Credit scoreTravis Dove for The New York Cases

“Phrases like their moments, especially colloquialisms,” said the linguist Robin Lakoff, professor emerita on the College of California, Berkeley, whose 1975 guide, “Language and Lady’s Space,” helped accomplish the area of gender linguistics. “Ceaselessly, after a note or phrase will get rather lots of exercise, folk merely close the utilization of it — attributable to we treasure to sound favorite and this one appears to be like tired.”

Which just isn’t any longer to suppose it is entirely verboten — or that metaphorical ceilings are no longer surely being shattered. Kirsten Gillibrand tweeted the time interval this month as fragment of a pledge for gender parity in nationwide security, while Marianne Williamson notes on her marketing campaign online web page that the “proverbial glass ceiling” is definitely one of many issues maintaining ladies folks wait on.

Aside from the file-breaking different of female candidates for president — alongside with those serving in Congress — there are extra ladies folks CEOs within the Fortune 500 than ever earlier than (though, of direction, that number is restful merely 33), and a fresh sight published within the journal American Psychologist came upon that a majority of American citizens think about ladies folks are only as competent as males — if no longer extra.

“It’s a reasonably dramatic shift,” said Alice Eagly, a social psychologist at Northwestern College who led the work, analyzing public perceptions over 70 years.

As a time interval, the “glass ceiling” dates to spherical 1978, when it used to be mentioned by female workers at Hewlett-Packard and frequent onstage at a panel discussion about ladies folks’s aspirations by an employee of the New York Phone Co. Each and every frequent it to whine the shortcoming of white-collar ladies folks to rise previous the mid-manager stage of their jobs, and the in most cases invisible boundaries stopping that rise.

The phrase received traction within the mid-Eighties, when it regarded in an editorial in Adweek (quoting the outgoing editor of Working Lady journal) and then a headline in The Wall Boulevard Journal (“The Glass Ceiling: Why Ladies Can’t Seem to Atomize the Invisible Barrier That Blocks Them From the Top Jobs”). The New York Cases ran an editorial in 1986 — the identical year it proclaimed that, architecturally talking, structures made of look-via glass had been “getting merely reports”— referring to the glass ceiling for female politicians, quoting Betty Friedan, co-founding father of the National Organization for Ladies.

“Our ladies folks tried to head better and I wonder whether or not they ran into a glass ceiling,” Ms. Friedan said then, recalling the unsuccessful campaigns of Carol Bellamy for mayor of New York, Elizabeth Holtzman for Congress and Geraldine Ferraro for vp. “In corporations, ladies folks catch to a center stage and then there’s a glass ceiling — no longer overt discrimination, merely a feeling that you just might well drag this high and no better.”

Within the years following, the time interval persisted to head mainstream — a extra or much less linguistic shorthand for a question that can perhaps perhaps additionally very neatly be great to pinpoint or recount. By the Nineties it had been frequent to whine the experiences of Navy ladies folks, female attorneys, ladies folks in banking, older ladies folks, black experts (ladies folks and males), ladies folks who labored on the selling campaign of George Bush and the quandary of female journalists — as explained by The Washington Post’s board chair on the time, Katharine Graham.

Extra no longer too long ago, it has been uttered by the likes of Priyanka Chopra, the actor Brie Larson (who this year completed Captain Shock in a uncommon female-led superhero movie) and Madeleine Albright, who wore a glass-ceiling brooch to the Democratic National Convention in 2016.

Peaceable, no one has frequent the allegory rather treasure Mrs. Clinton, who has for years talked referring to the “highest, hardest glass ceiling” she used to be resolute to crack. She spoke of it movingly in her 2008 concession speech, announcing that while she used to be no longer in a scheme to atomize it, the ceiling now had “about 18 million cracks.”

Eight years later, when she became the first female nominee of a important social gathering’s price, she leaned into the metaphor even more difficult. When she spoke by video to the Democratic National Convention a virtual glass ceiling broke onscreen; she accredited the nomination later within the week while announcing, “When there don’t appear to be any ceilings, the sky’s the limit.”

And then, of direction, there used to be the fateful night on the Javits Heart in New york, below a literal glass ceiling where confetti fashioned treasure glass shards used to be speculated to rain from above as Mrs. Clinton acknowledged victory.


Credit scoreTodd Heisler/The New York Cases

“I consider pondering that the symbolism used to be going to surely feel so nice,” said Emma Gray, 31, who reports on ladies folks’s complications for HuffPost and remembers staring upward throughout a quiet 2d on the Javits Heart on election night. “We had been below a literal glass ceiling and that ceiling used to be going to metaphorically atomize. And then it did no longer.”

The next morning, Mrs. Clinton gave a concession speech and Google Search results for “glass ceiling” peaked, better even than their outdated peak throughout the Democratic National Convention that summer time. She worthy somberly that while “now we like restful no longer shattered that highest and hardest glass ceiling,” somebody would, no longer without lengthen.

With six ladies folks within the 2020 disappear, most likely the phrase appears to be like “nearly a diminutive of bit embarrassing, or even merely beside the purpose,” said Ms. Lakoff, the linguist, adding that “of direction it’s no longer.”

Which just isn’t any longer to suppose that the candidates are fascinated about gender any much less. To the different, the much less they focus on about it the extra it might well perhaps perhaps additionally uncover they’re surely fascinated about it extra.

“There’s a agonize that while you procedure too noteworthy attention to those biases, to your womanhood, that it reinforces folk’s doubts about it,” said Adam Grant, an organizational psychologist on the Wharton College of Industry, pointing to learn from the company world that illustrated that time. “So if I had been a female candidate on this cycle, which I realize is a irregular sentence to suppose, I might well perhaps be nervous that talking referring to the glass ceiling would fully toughen it.”

And, anyway, there are numerous terms to debris spherical with for the time being — akin to “glass cliff,” to whine the phenomenon of girls folks and minorities being tasked with leadership throughout classes of disaster, which used to be no longer too long ago added to (The “cliff” fragment is the premise that they’re being space as much as fail.)

Or “motherhood penalty” to whine bias namely in opposition to working mothers and “likability entice” to refer to the sphere female leaders face by having to existing they’re great and likable at once.

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the 29-year-dilapidated congresswoman from New York, has opted for “shake the desk” and “accomplish our like dwelling” to whine breaking boundaries, while Ayanna S. Pressley, the first black lady elected to Congress from Massachusetts, has worthy that, “With regards to ladies folks of coloration candidates, folks don’t merely focus on about a glass ceiling. What they recount is a concrete one.”


Credit scoreTiffany Brown Anderson for The New York Cases

This time spherical, Ms. Klobuchar worthy that the time interval itself isn’t merely about winning the White Dwelling — it’s about running within the first situation. The different of girls folks within the disappear is “a testomony to the growth now we like made,” she said.

“There are restful boundaries, but the highest and hardest glass ceiling has so many cracks in it, it is neatly on its manner to turning into an outdated frequent.”

Sharon Attia contributed learn.

Extra protection of gender and the 2020 disappear

Read More